The House Of The Dragon's finale has already started many conversations among fans, especially as they will have to wait until 2024 for season 2 to see the Greens and the Blacks' next move. However, many fans are still curious about the plot throughout the first season.
Some of these viewers think there are some inconsistencies within the story, leaving several plot holes that don't fit the storyline and the Game of Thrones world. While there are some confusing aspects of the story, including characterization and complex world building, these details aren't actually plot holes in season 1.
Aemma's C-Section
Some fans believe one of Viserys' worst decisions as king was pushing Aemma to continue trying to have a son despite her difficult pregnancies. However, some viewers were also confused about the practicality of the C-section performed on Aemma and didn't think the explanation behind this procedure was justifiable.
While this seems historically inaccurate and, therefore, creates an inconsistency in the plot, it's important to remember that fantastical worlds can establish different rules that might not apply to the period they're based on. Though a medieval-type C-section seems out of place, it fits into the story in the way the maester explains it.
Daemon Surviving In The Stepstones
Most viewers were impressed with the scene in which Daemon confronts the Crabfeeder and his army. However, some fans had a problem with Daemon's ability to dodge arrows while he was out on an open field being shot at by several bowmen.
While this does seem implausible, it isn't completely unreasonable that someone trained in combat would know how to avoid being shot on a battlefield, especially with minimum obstacles. This scene may use plot armor to protect Daemon's character, but it's still not the most nonsensical battle scene in the Game of Thrones world.
Laenor And Seasmoke Saving Daemon
Another aspect of this battle scene viewers thought didn't make any sense was Laenor getting the jump on the Crabfeeder and the triarchy soldiers. Since they had been diligent in checking the skies for dragons when Daemon arrived, it was a bit hard to believe Seasmoke was able to take them by surprise.
There are a few details that made this scene more plausible. Since the soldiers were focusing on Daemon, and assuming he was alone, it's possible they were not as diligent in checking their surroundings. The Stepstones' cloudiness could have also provided the smaller dragon coverage for a sneak attack.
Ser Criston Killing Joffrey
Some viewers found Ser Criston's assault on Joffrey at Laenor and Rhaenyra's wedding completely unbelievable. Not only did there not seem to be a cause for the assault, but fans weren't convinced he wouldn't have had any punishment for this crime.
However, Criston's current state of mind made it rational that he would attack someone that was suggesting his immoral behavior was appropriate. Furthermore, Alicent's influence in the court and Viserys' lack of restricting her fight for power means that Alicent likely protected Criston from any punishment, which may explain why there were no consequences for his heinous act.
The Illegitimacy Rumors
While all the Targaryens have bad personality traits, one thing they have in common is their dedication to their house. Therefore, many viewers don't understand why so many people, including those within the Targaryen family, wouldn't have tried harder to discredit Rhaenyra's children and their claim to the throne.
But one aspect about the bastard-born princes is that it's not as easy as it seems to prove they aren't Laenor Velaryon's. Though it's odd they don't look like Velaryons, Rhaenyra also has Baratheon and Arryn blood, whose lines have traits that fit the two princes' physical characteristics.
Alicent Not Being Punished
One of Alicent's worst decisions in season 1 is when she attacks Rhaenyra with a knife, injuring the princess. In regard to this scene, some viewers aren't convinced that Alicent wouldn't have been punished for attacking the heir after the king had demanded an end to the conflict.
However, it's not a plot hole that Alicent's actions are just forgotten. Another king may have had her severely punished or even exiled, but the king is not known as Viserys the Peaceful for nothing. Given how passive Viserys is, it makes sense he wouldn't want to act on his wife's disobedience.
Rhaenys Escaping With Meleys
Rhaenys interrupting Aegon's coronation was one of the most impressive scenes in the first season. However, some might wonder how she got to Meleys after Erryk warned her that's the first place they expected her to go after her escape.
Considering the need to get on with Aegon's coronation quickly, it's quite possible the Greens hadn't yet realized Rhaenys was missing from her chambers. In addition, the dragonkeepers in the dragon pit are dedicated to the dragons and the Targaryens, so it's unlikely political tensions would affect them and drive them to try to stop Rhaenys from mounting her own dragon.
Seasmoke Getting A New Rider
In "The Black Queen," the Blacks discussed the fact that they had the advantage of more dragons on their side, including dragons without riders like Seasmoke. However, since his rider isn't dead, fans are confused as to how anyone could ride him into battle.
The standard rule in this world is that a dragon normally doesn't let another rider on them unless their old one has died. However, since Laenor abandoned the dragon and has not been around Seasmoke in years, and the intelligence of dragons hasn't been entirely established, it's possible Seasmoke would allow another rider to claim him.
Daemon's Abusive Behavior
Daemon is considered one of the evilest Targaryens in House of the Dragon. Despite that fact, viewers were shocked to see him be so aggressive with Rhaenyra and thought it was out of character, considering how he had refused to do her harm in the past.
While it may have seemed out of character for Daemon at this moment, it actually makes a lot of sense for his erratic characterization. Though he clearly cares about Rhaenyra, he has proven multiple times that he struggles to control his emotions. Considering he had just lost a child, his brother, and is preparing for a war, it fit his personality that he'd convey his emotions poorly.
The Line Of Succession
One of the show's most complex aspects – and the main aspect that starts the war between the Targaryens – is the line of succession. Since the law of the realm considers the first male son of the king the rightful heir, it seems odd to some viewers that Viserys would be able to name Rhaenyra his heir against Westerosi tradition.
Though King Jaehaerys allowed his Great Council to choose Viserys as his heir, the king traditionally had the right to name an heir. It was unorthodox for Viserys to name Rhaenyra his heir, but, despite Westerosi tradition, he was still allowed to do so. It might seem as though dismissing this tradition is a plot hole to create a conflict, but Viserys' decision was his to make and the reason Rhaenyra has a rightful claim to the Iron Throne.
Source:gamerant.com